Ben 10 Club
    • Register
    • Login
    • Popular
    • Recent
    • Tags
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    • Donate
    1. Home
    2. csgt
    3. Posts
    • Profile
    • Following 0
    • Followers 7
    • Topics 4
    • Posts 88
    • Best 39
    • Controversial 0
    • Groups 0

    Posts made by csgt

    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @tactical-ochoa said in Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2:

      @csgt Yes, the sequel shows certainly downplayed Kevin's powers, which is something that I wasn't fond of and found to not make much or any sense. Actually, no, Kevin's powers didn't really change in the sequel shows. Absorbing matter wasn't a change. It was an addition. (...) Kevin's powers weren't really downplayed. Stuff was just added to them in a way that didn't make much sense to me. Kevin's powers had always been focused on absorbing some form of energy and mutating from absorbing too much energy.

      I'm really sorry, I didn't understand what you meant here because first you agreed with me that the sequels downplayed Kevin's powers, but then you disagreed.

      What I was trying to say: Yes, in the sequels Kevin still technically could absorb energy, sure, he didn't lose his powers, but at the same time, he stopped using them (with very few exceptions, like the Ultimate Kevin arc). But what I'm saying is, don't look at what Kevin could do (absorb energy/matter), look at what he actually does with this power.

      In the OS, Kevin:

      • Turned into aliens (in "Framed", he turned into the exact same alien forms as Ben, and in "Kevin 11" when he mutated into a hybrid Heatblast and a hybrid Four Arms)
      • Turned into amalgam alien forms ( in the end of "Framed" he turned into his classic almagam form fusing Ben's ten first aliens, stayed like that during "Grudge Match" and "Back With A Vengeance", and later in "Ken 10" he turned into another amalgam form, Kevin 11K)

      Most of the time in the OS (except for the very beginning of "Kevin 11" where he used a bit of electricity) what we actually see is Kevin going alien.

      While in the sequels most of the time what we see is him creating a shell of metal, rubber and other kinds of stuff around himself. We rarely see Kevin going alien like he used to in the OS (with a few exceptions, of course). That's why I said the alien side was downplayed and his powerset was changed.

      Why the sequels did that? Because going alien was already Ben's thing, if they had kept Kevin using his powers like he did in the OS, it would be redudant and/or make Ben useless. So they used Kevin's powers in a completely different way.

      That's what I refered to as a powerset change.

      It nerfs Kevin into being somewhere around Ben's level (although, that is dependent on what aliens Kevin can use and whether or not he could splice them together into some amalgamation). Kevin having an Omnitrix limits his level of power to what he has access to; especially compared to Kevin's energy absorption ability, which allows Kevin to become more and more powerful the more energy he absorbs. It could kill at least most of the tension that comes from Ben and Kevin fighting each other because, again, Kevin having his own Omnitrix puts him around the same level that Ben is at, thus making Kevin less of a threat compared to him being able to absorb energy

      Well, again, if with his Omnitrix Kevin can use aliens and if he can splice them together into amalgamations, then he is doing the same stuff he always did in the OS.

      I agree with you, technically, Kevin's energy absorption ability allows Kevin to become more and more powerful the more energy he absorbs, but when in the OS did he actually presented a bigger threat to Ben by using his energy absorption powers to do something different than turn into an alien or an amalgamation of aliens? I honestly can't remember.

      (although again, that is if Kevin's Omnitrix works the same way as Ben's Omnitrix, which I'm guessing is going to be the case in the reboot show).

      My guess, initially, it will be the same as OS Kevin. Just like in Kevin 11 and Framed, Kevin initially only used single alien forms. From the end of Framed onwards, he used amalgam forms, so I guess later in the Reboot, his Omnitrix will allow him to use almagam forms too. Just a guess though.

      And your example with Quicksilver and Scarlet Witch is terrible.

      Alright, I will try a better example then. It's a bit obscure, so you might not be familiar with this. Spider-Gwen in the Ultimate Spider-Man cartoon. In the comics, she had full powers, in the cartoon she had a high tech suit to simulate Spider-Man's powers. http://thedailybugle.wikia.com/wiki/Spider-Gwen
      Or a more mainstream example, Spider-Man himself in the first trilogy had organic web instead of web-shooters.
      Of course, there is always a polemic with these changes, but I just want to show that things like this have been done before.

      . Given what Rouleau said, I wouldn't even be surprised if Man of Action make Kevin a good guy again...if he even is going to be evil in the reboot show.

      I guess he is, because of what I said earlier. Giving him an Omnitrixi and making him an ally would be kind of redudant in my opinion. If they wanted a second heroic Omnitrix user, they could have gone with Gwen, making her like Gwen 10, at least that way it would have the gender diversity. So I'm guessing he will be evil. Again, just a guess.

      Also, Kevin doesn't need his own Omnitrix to further mirror Ben. They did that with Albedo and it didn't work as well as Kevin did in the Original Series. Albedo was just an evil Galvan with Ben's appearance and a replica of the original Omnitrix. That's not a proper, evil counterpart to Ben. Albedo was an entirely different character compared to Ben. OS Kevin was the true, ideal dark mirror image of Ben and OS Kevin never had his own Omnitrix during that time. Kevin paralleled Ben in some ways but also differed from Ben as well. Kevin was a reminder to Ben of what Ben could've become if it weren't for his first meeting with Kevin.

      I completely agree with you there.

      Kevin to Ben was like The Joker to Batman. Ben's view of Kevin was like Luke Skywalker's vision of Darth Vader on Dagobah in Star Wars: Empire Strikes Back. Do you see The Joker don some sort of uniform or battle suit that looks similar to Batman's outfit? No. Do you see Luke Skywalker wear a full armored suit like Vader does? No. Objects don't always present two characters being proper opposites to each other and I don't find that to be subtle either. It comes down to the characters themselves and their personalities and traits, which I find has a better chance of being more subtle. When symbolism and whatnot is shoved into the viewers' faces, usually it could end up being seen as intrusive and insulting of the viewers' intelligence. I find it better to be more subtle and put confidence in the viewers to be able to figure stuff out. Kevin doesn't need his own Omnitrix in order to be a better representation of being a dark mirror image of Ben and the Original Series is proof of that.

      Alright, but you also have example of non-subtle opposite characters, and they work too.
      alt text
      alt text

      Going back to Kevin's powers being removed and replaced by him having his own Omnitrix, taking away Kevin's powers does a lot more to Kevin than just change his power set. It changes Kevin as a character. In the context of the Original Series, Kevin was kicked out by his family because of his powers. Kevin was bullied and treated like a freak by others because of his powers. Kevin's mental instability and insanity as well as his psychopathic behavior was there because of his powers. Kevin's ability to absorb energy was a huge and long term fundamental aspect about him that made and defined Kevin for who he is. Take away those powers and Kevin isn't Kevin anymore. Take away those powers and you take away Kevin as a character.

      I actually agree with you on that. Changing the powers do make Kevin a less complex character. But, despite that, MOA can still find other reasons for Kevin to be bullied or rejected by his family, if they actually want to work on his backstory. I believe that they can still keep his old personality (even if they don't fully develop his backstory). Considering that the sequel already changed Kevin's personality to make him a hero, if MOA at least keep the same personality Kevin had in the OS, I'm already satisfied.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @Tactical-Ochoa (I had replied to you on reddit, but decided to reply here instead)

      If we look at Kevin in the OS, the only case I remember of him actually absorbing non-alien energy is when he absorbed electricity in his very first appearance, and it was only in the beginning of the episode. Later, all he did was absorb alien energy and use alien forms. He emulated Ben's alien forms in "Framed", then he became an amalgam of Ben's aliens by the end of the episode, and, in the future, he became Kevin 11.000 (an even more dangerous amalgam of aliens).

      To differentiate Kevin's power-set from Ben's, the sequels (AF/UA/OV) heavily downplayed the alien side, and focused on the absorbing side - they made him absorb matter, which wasn't even part of his original power-set. Then the sequels introduced Albedo to fill Kevin's original role.

      Kevin having an Omnitrix doesn't change much of Kevin's OS power-set. With an Omnitrix, Kevin can emulate Ben's aliens like he did in Framed, and he can become an amalgam creature (that happened to Ben in Innervasion, it can easily happen to Kevin too).

      It's like what the MCU did with Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver. They are mutants in the comics, but since they couldn't use mutants in the film, they made them be genetic experiments. It changed the origin of their powers, but it didn't change their powerset itself.

      Why MOA is doing that? I might be very wrong, but my guess is that they want to distance their Kevin from UAF/OV Kevin, because what the sequels did to him was never their plan, and present him as a "dark mirror" of Ben like they always wanted - and giving him an Omnitrix is a way to visually establish that to the viewers (like the sequels did with Albedo).

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @tactical-ochoa said in Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2:

      "the Omnitrix is now a gateway through to where an evil alien empire will invade Earth"
      Wow. What a way to make the Omnitrix seem less like, well, the Omnitrix.

      I'm pretty sure that this isn't a permanent change, just a one-time-only thing too. "The Omnitrix is now a gateway" I mean, you could say about Secret of the Omnitrix, "The Omnitrix is now a time bomb that can destroy the entire universe"

      My bet is that by the end of the season finale the Omnitrix will be fully back to normal, and maybe without the Omni-Enhanced aliens (if I'm correct, I won't miss them)

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 2016 Reboot Episode Review: The Charm Offensive

      You certainly raised good points, @Tactical-Ochoa , but I have a few things to point out:

      "Even her UAF design looks better and more unique than this new reboot design"
      Well, I don't think UAF Charmcaster design is unique at all. It was completely different from OS Charmcaster's design and was turned into a carbon copy of Marvel's Enchantress.
      alt text
      .
      .
      But I don't like Reboot Charmcaster's design either. My favorite design for Charmcaster is Original Series, then my second favorite is Omniverse (because it looks more like the OS). I don't really like any of the others.
      alt text

      I completely agree that removing Hex from Charmcaster's backstory in the reboot was not a good idea, and removed a lot of depth from the character. I really hope they establish some connection between Hex and Charmcaster later in the Reboot.

      "Is there at least anything that Charmcaster has that resembles, well, Charmcaster?" Fair point, but UAF Charmcaster was also completely different from Original Charmcaster. She was Hope, she was born in Ledgerdomain, her motivation was to ressurect her dead father Spellbinder, none of these aspects fit the character presented in the Original Series at all. I still think that Reboot Charmcaster, as a human teen delinquent girl that has magic powers, is closer to the OS version, and I think there is room for more character development in the future.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @Tactical-Ochoa Yes, this episode was definitely MOA's own take on Couples Retreat.

      There were many similarities, but I will talk about a few diffences that in my opinion actually made The Charm Offensive more enjoyable than Couples Retreat.

      At least here it makes sense for Charmcaster to be manipulated by Morningstar, because it was her very first appearance and she was younger and still naive, unlike in UA where Charmcaster supposedly had years of experience and being played by Morningstar was a big character regression and made her look pathetic.

      Now, let's analyse the developments we get from this episode. By the end of the episode Ben corrects Grandpa Max when he implies that Gwen is a helper/sidekick and Ben says that Gwen is a full-fledged hero. While in Couples Retreat, Kevin messed up, didn't trust Gwen to keep a spellbook safe, moved it from her house to his garage, which actually made it easier for Morningstar to steal it and then in the end of the episode... Gwen forgives him and concludes he's a good boyfriend just because he's not as bad as Morningstar. Gwevin crappiness at its prime. So when it comes to character development, I much prefer the character developments between Ben and Gwen in "The Charm Offensive" over the character "developments" (if we can call it developments) between Kevin and Gwen in "Couples Retreat".

      About Charmcaster looking weak, well, in the end, even after she had been drained, she managed to overpower Morningstar, trapped him in her book and Ben and Gwen looked terrified of her, so I think she actually looked quite strong.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      I found Charmcaster's debut episode in english on Youtube, if anyone is interested.
      Part 1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tIORt1cvhM4
      Part 2 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8__C045ma1s

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Will kai become bens love interest?

      @mortie-10 I do think that Eunice is a better choice than Julie too.
      Julie might have Ship/battle armor, but still she almost never used that. In fact, she always prefered to play tennis and live a normal life instead of fighting alongside Ben against his enemies. Considering how important being a hero is to Ben, a girlfriend who doesn't fully support him with that is incompatible to him, and that put a strain in their relationship. That's why I mentioned Gwen, Charmcaster and Looma: Gwen (my first choice) was Ben's partner ever since day one, she always stood by his side and helped him to fight enemies, even before she had magic. Charmcaster, if developed in a proper way, could also be Ben's partner too. Looma, as a warrior princess, also could help Ben in battle. Eunice, as you mentioned, also showed potential to be an heroic partner to Ben. While Julie is usually not by Ben's side when he is doing his hero stuff, on the contrary, Ben doesn't spend much time with her because being a hero gets in the way of their relationship.

      About Julie being cute, well, when Ben met Kai and Eunice you could see him almost drooling, that wasn't the reaction he had when he met Julie. Besides, for example, you could see a lot of guys "noticing" Gwen's looks (Cooper, Kevin, Morningstar, the Forever Knight's squire, even Kid Ben with the infamous 'big butt' comment...) while in UAF we never see anyone else showing interest in Julie. I think Julie wasn't supposed to be much attractive. Of course, it's ok if we have different opinions about that, but I'm trying to present evidence from the show that seem to imply that, in fact, the characters in-universe don't see Julie as that much attractive.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Will kai become bens love interest?

      Please, not Julie. Julie is the very definition of 'satellite love interest', a generic female character with a bland personality and no interesting traits who appeared every once in a while just to remind the audience that Ben had a girlfriend.

      Kai is a slightly better option, but I still think there are better choices, like Gwen, Charmcaster, Looma... But I actually hope the Reboot stays away from romance. The dynamic between Ben and Gwen is great, and shoehorning love interests between them would probably be a mistake.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      It seems like it's Vilgax's ship. Since Ben looks like Upgrade, Grandpa Max looks like Cannonbolt and Gwen seems to be Stinkfly, I'd say that maybe Vilgax is messing with their DNAs and the hybrid creature is Vilgax himself (the form is probably just a small nod to Kevin, just like Amalgam Ben). If It were Kevin, I think we'd see the hair or something resembling him, but that's just a guess.

      alt text

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      I've found a small clip of the episode here (but the dub is german)
      http://themattress.tumblr.com/post/173001051073

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @ebomnitrix said in Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2:

      Episode 21-26 have been announced to air in CN Germany in April, and usually when it airs in Germany, its 3-6 weeks later than the UK.
      https://www.fernsehserien.de/ben-10-2016/episodenguide

      Charmcaster almost might be coming, stay tuned...

      From the description of the episode "The Charm Offensive" found here: https://www.fernsehserien.de/ben-10-2016/folgen/2x26-gwens-erzfeinde-1184036

      I don't know a thing about german, but Charmcaster is definitely going to appear because her name was mentioned!! I'm very hyped for it

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: My Biggest Issue with Goodbye and Good Riddance

      @tactical-ochoa said in My Biggest Issue with Goodbye and Good Riddance:

      @ungrateful-wolf Also, Alien Force premiered 3 days after Goodbye and Good Riddance first aired.

      So my second theory is definitely not valid. MOA was fully aware they wouldn't get another season. My first theory might still be true, though (Goodbye conflicted with Alien Force, and as a last minute change, CN made MOA turn it into a "What if" episode)

      posted in Episodes
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: My Biggest Issue with Goodbye and Good Riddance

      I think I basically agree with @Ebomnitrix. I will post here the same theories that I posted on reddit, just so other people can know my theories too:

      1. If you look at the Ben 10K timeline, Ben's and Gwen's identities are not a secret, so it's a safe bet to assume that the creators of the show, Man Of Action (MOA for short) always toyed with the idea of having the identities exposed. Maybe they wanted to end the OS with the reveal and explore it in Hero Generation (MOA's intended sequel for the OS). But it wouldn't fit with Cartoon Network's idea for the sequel, Alien Force (McDuffie's show), so maybe CN forced Man of Action to make 'Goodbye' into a what-if episode. Granted, a lot of things from the OS didn't fit with Alien Force - like Kevin's personality, or the Plumbers being a human organization - but most of these things were from earlier seasons, and probably Cartoon Network didn't decide to replace Man Of Action until much later, after all this had already been made.

      .

      1. MOA wasn't sure if they would get a 5th season or not, so, if they didn't, ending the show on a high note, with the end of the summer and Ben's identity being exposed, was the way they wanted to go out. But if they did get another season with 10-year-old Ben, then they kept the door open to keep the "status-quo" so they made it "non-canon" as an insurance policy for themselves.

      .

      Even though, I really dislike using "canon" and "non-canon", because the word "canon" is used as a reference to the UAF/OV timeline, and this timeline is currently discontinued, so today Goodbye and Good Riddance is just as "canonical" as UAF/OV (both are part of their own separate canons) The current . official canon is now in fact the Reboot with multiple video-games and toylines based on it (whether we like it or not) I think I'll also post my other thread here about it.

      posted in Episodes
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @ultimate-omnitri I'm not so sure. Back in Season 2 of the original Ben 10 show, we got two new aliens, Cannonbolt and Wildvine. While we did lost Ghostfreak for a while, we actually had 11 aliens, so the concept of having more than 10 aliens was present very early in the franchise. I think they changed their minds about it later.

      I hope Upgrade comes back in a future season. They set up Shock Rock to be Ben's 11th alien, but he's actually Ben's new 10th alien, that was really unfair in my opinion.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @andrew42

      I agree with many things from this video, but I also think Kuro The Artist glossed over some things (mainly the viewership decline that led to AF's third season tonal shift). I will write here the comment I sent him:

      "I feel the viewership decline from the two first seasons of Alien Force have a very clear reason: While I do agree with you that storytelling was better and at its prime, the characters simply... weren't. And a long-running franchise success is always because of its characters, not just a story, no matter how good.

      You mentioned you can't picture Bloxx on the Original Show continuity, I agree with you. But I also can't picture Ben, Gwen and Kevin from Alien Force in the Original Show continuity. Back in the Original Show, Kevin was a total psycho who tried to kill both Ben and Gwen on several occasions and backstabbed Ben every time Ben offered him a chance. In Alien Force, they simply pretend Kevin was never that bad and quickly accept him into the team before the first episode is over. In Original Series, Gwen is a badass and smart girl. In Alien Force, Gwen's new personality is being an infatuated schoolgirl who likes to smell Kevin's sweaty handkerchief (Kevin's Big Score) and who pratically begs him to ask her out (All That Glitters). Ben was funny in the original show. While I do agree he should be more mature at 15, he could still have been funny (like Spider-Man), but he was way too serious, and took attitudes - like taking off the Omnitrix - that didn't fit his character and were never properly explained on the show. Besides, I don't think the new 10 aliens were as interesting as the first 10 aliens from the original show. They shouldn't have replaced ALL of them right off the bat.

      So I do feel people simply saw that the characters from Alien Force didn't feel like the Classic characters and abandoned the show. Then, everything went downhill as CN desperately tried to bring those viewers back but only lost even more viewers."

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: New game announced!!

      @tactical-ochoa Brazil. In my currency, R$1 = US$ 3.3, so if the game costs US$ 30 for you in USA, it should be around R$100 in my country's currency. If I'm correct, I'll wait for a sale with at least 60% of discount (which may not happen soon).

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: New game announced!!

      I can't find it on the Playstation Store either. I won't buy it until there's a really good sale, but I was curious to see how much the game would cost on my country now (even though I'm sure it won't be cheap)

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @tactical-ochoa The Weatherheads appear in this other clip https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6QhM4jzvZMA

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @tactical-ochoa I found this other clip elsewhere https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVcYZb_wo4c

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt
    • RE: Ben 10 Reboot Discussion Part 1: Season 2

      @ebomnitrix Are you sure? The Weatherheads are also featured in the episode, the snow and ice could be their doing.

      posted in Ben 10 Reboot
      csgt
      csgt